How the Early Universe Supercharged Black Hole Growth

Chaotic Beginnings for Cosmic Giants

Astronomers have long known that supermassive black holes – objects millions to billions of times the mass of the Sun – already existed less than a billion years after the Big Bang. Explaining how they grew so large so quickly has been one of modern cosmology’s toughest puzzles.

A new study from researchers at Maynooth University in Ireland, published in Nature Astronomy, offers a compelling answer. Using advanced computer simulations, the team finds that the extreme, gas-rich conditions of the early universe allowed small, “seed” black holes to undergo brief but intense feeding frenzies, rapidly ballooning into the giants seen by today’s telescopes.

Feeding Frenzies in Young Galaxies

In the simulations, the first generation of black holes – formed just a few hundred million years after the Big Bang – sit inside dense, turbulent galaxies packed with cold gas. Instead of growing slowly over billions of years, these black holes experience episodes of so-called super-Eddington accretion, where they pull in matter faster than standard physics would normally allow.

Under ordinary conditions, radiation from infalling material should blow gas away and choke off further growth. But in the chaotic early universe, the simulations show that gas can pile up around young black holes faster than radiation can expel it. This lets them gain mass at extraordinary rates, reaching tens of thousands of solar masses in a relatively short cosmic time.

The results help explain recent observations from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), which has revealed surprisingly massive black holes in very distant, early galaxies. The new work suggests that many of these monsters may have started as ordinary, “light-seed” black holes that simply had access to unusually rich fuel supplies.

Competing Ideas for the First Black Holes

Astrophysicists broadly group early black hole origins into two main scenarios. In the light-seed picture, black holes form as the remnants of the universe’s first massive stars, with initial masses of a few tens to a few hundred Suns. To reach supermassive scales, they must then grow dramatically through mergers and accretion.

In the heavy-seed scenario, by contrast, some black holes may have been born already huge – tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of solar masses – through the direct collapse of massive gas clouds in primitive galaxies. Recent JWST observations, including objects like the so-called “Infinity Galaxy,” have been interpreted by some teams as evidence for these direct-collapse black holes.

The new Maynooth simulations strengthen the case that light seeds can, under the right conditions, grow fast enough to explain at least part of the early population of supermassive black holes. However, many researchers argue that both channels may be at work, with some black holes starting small and growing rapidly, while others are born heavy in rare environments.

What Webb and Future Telescopes May Reveal

As JWST continues to survey the distant universe, astronomers are gathering a growing sample of young galaxies hosting actively feeding black holes. By measuring their masses, growth rates, and environments, researchers hope to disentangle which formation pathways dominate.

Future observatories, such as the planned next-generation X-ray and gravitational-wave missions, could probe black hole growth in even more detail – for example, by detecting mergers between early black holes or by tracing high-energy radiation from their accretion disks.

For now, the new simulations offer a crucial piece of the puzzle: in a dense, turbulent early universe, even relatively small black holes could grow up fast. That helps bridge the gap between the first stars and the gargantuan black holes that anchor today’s galaxies, including our own Milky Way.

Chaotic Beginnings for Cosmic Giants

Feeding Frenzies in Young Galaxies

Competing Ideas for the First Black Holes

What Webb and Future Telescopes May Reveal

References